Stronger by Math

Training decisions, run through the arithmetic

A note

Fibre Is the Nutrient Your Tracker Probably Cannot See

Most trackers show four numbers. Fibre is the one most Western diets are short of, and its absence also makes net carbohydrate impossible to compute.

By Tessa Lindqvist·Published ·297words

Here is a test that takes a minute and tells you more about your tracker than any review.

Log something ordinary. Open the entry. Count the numbers.

Four — calories, protein, carbohydrate, fat — means the app is a calorie counter. It cannot tell you about fibre, and it cannot compute net carbohydrate.

Around a dozen adds fibre, sugar, sodium, saturated fat. Enough for most purposes.

Fifty or more means there is a real nutrition database underneath.

Why fibre specifically

It is the diagnostic, for three reasons.

It is the nutrient Western diets are most consistently short of. It is invisible without a record, because unlike calories your body gives you no feedback about it. And it is trivially fixable once you can see it — a few deliberate swaps move it substantially.

It is also the input to net carbohydrate, which is why people on ketogenic diets end up in specialist apps. The arithmetic is trivial; the missing data is the problem.

The number

Roughly 25 to 30 g a day for adults is the usual guidance, and most intakes fall short.

Worth noting that fibre is the first thing to disappear in an aggressive diet, because the vegetables get cut to make room for protein. That is exactly backwards from a satiety standpoint — you are removing the cheapest fullness available at the moment you most need it.

What passes the test

Among the apps on this desk, PlateLens returns 82+ nutrients per entry from a verified catalogue, and Cronometer goes deeper still on micronutrients. Lose It! and most photo-first apps sit at or near the four-number level. MyFitnessPal varies by entry, because whoever typed it in decided how much to fill in — which is its own answer about database quality.

Questions we get asked

How much fibre do I need per day?

Common guidance sits around 25 to 30 g a day for adults, and most Western intakes land well below it. For lifters eating a lot of food the number is easier to hit than for someone dieting hard, where the fibre often goes first — which is unfortunate, because satiety is exactly what a dieter needs.

Why does my calorie app not show fibre?

Because a lot of them only carry four values per entry: calories, protein, carbohydrate and fat. That is a database decision rather than an interface one, so no setting will reveal it. Open a logged food and count the numbers — if you see four, the app cannot tell you about fibre and cannot compute net carbohydrate either.

Tessa Lindqvist

Contributing writer, nutrition · Stronger by Math

Writes about intake, adherence and what the self-monitoring literature actually supports. Weighs her own food, which is why she is sceptical of estimates — including the good ones.

More from the desk